Hi Bob,

I don't know if you'll still read this, but I have a case (08933438 and 08943094) about a bug with seeAllData I think I have found. Two tests doing exactly the same this, one has see all data and passes, the other does not and fails.

@IsTest
private class SFDCTestSeeAllDataBug {

	@IsTest(seeAllData=true)
	private static void testSeeAllDataCorrectBehaviour() {
		Project__c project = new Project__c(Name='SeeAllData True Project');
		insert project;
		Work__c subscription = new Work__c(
			RecordTypeId = RecordTypeHelper.workSubscription.Id,
			OwnerId = UserInfo.getUserId(),
			Project__c=project.Id
		);
		insert subscription;
		
		Work__c queryedSubscription = [
			SELECT
				Id,
				Project__c,
				Owner.IsActive
			FROM
				Work__c
			WHERE
				Owner.IsActive = true
				AND Project__c = :project.Id
		];
		System.assert(queryedSubscription.Owner.IsActive);
	}

	@IsTest(seeAllData=false)
	private static void testSeeAllDataBug() {
		Project__c project = new Project__c(Name='SeeAllData False Project');
		insert project;
		Work__c subscription = new Work__c(
			RecordTypeId = RecordTypeHelper.workSubscription.Id,
			OwnerId = UserInfo.getUserId(),
			Project__c=project.Id
		);
		insert subscription;
		
		List<Work__c> queryedSubscription = [
			SELECT
				Id,
				Project__c,
				Owner.IsActive
			FROM
				Work__c
			WHERE
				Owner.IsActive = true
				AND Project__c = :project.Id
		];
		System.assertEquals(1, queryedSubscription.size());
	}
}

 Could you confirm this is expected behaviour (as support is claiming). Because it doesn't look like to to me.